Toffees

What makes toffees so special?

Toffees hit that perfect sweet spot between hard and soft. They're made by heating sugar and butter to just the right temperature, creating that distinctive texture we all love. Unlike boiled sweets that shatter when you bite them, toffees give way with a satisfying chew. The magic happens at around 150°C, when the sugar transforms into something golden and delicious.

The beauty of toffees lies in their simplicity. Just a few ingredients, sugar, butter, and often cream or milk, come together to create something truly special. Some makers add vanilla, salt, or even chocolate to create different flavours, but the heart of a good toffee remains unchanged.

Which toffees should you try first?

If you're new to the world of toffees, start with the classics. Treacle toffee brings that deep, molasses flavour that's been a British favourite for decades. Butter toffee offers a pure, creamy taste that melts on your tongue. And English toffee? That's the one covered in chocolate and chopped nuts, brilliant with a cup of tea.

For something different, try rum and raisin toffees. They pack a grown-up punch that's perfect for after dinner. Or grab some cream toffees, they're softer than traditional varieties and practically melt in your mouth. We've even got vegan toffees made with plant-based ingredients so that everyone can enjoy them.

How do you store toffees properly?

Store them in an airtight container away from heat and moisture; your kitchen cupboard works perfectly. If they're individually wrapped, leave them that way; the wrappers protect each piece from sticking together.

Temperature matters too. Toffees can go a bit soft in summer heat or turn rock-hard in the cold. The room temperature is just right. And here's a tip: if your toffees do stick together, pop them in the fridge for an hour. They'll separate much more easily when cold.

What's the difference between toffee and other sweets?

Toffees occupy their special place in the sweet shop. They're firmer than chewy sweets but not as hard as traditional boiled sweets. The butter content sets them apart; it's what gives toffees their rich flavour and distinctive texture.

Unlike chocolate, which melts at body temperature, toffees hold their shape until you bite into them. They're more substantial than foam sweets but less intense than liquorice sweets. Think of them as the comfort food of the confectionery world, satisfying, familiar, and always reliable.

Can you make toffees at home?

Absolutely! Making toffees at home is easier. You'll need a sugar thermometer and a bit of patience, but the results are worth it. Start with a basic butter toffee recipe, just sugar, butter, and a splash of water. Heat slowly, stirring constantly, until you reach the hard crack stage.

The trick is timing. Pull the mixture off the heat too soon and you'll end up with something more like caramel. Leave it too long and you'll have something more complex than you bargained for. But get it right, and you'll have homemade toffees that rival anything from our traditional sweet collection.

Why do toffees stick to your teeth?

That sticky quality is part of toffee's charm! The combination of sugar and butter creates a texture that clings a bit as you chew. It's completely different from jelly sweets that bounce back or mints that dissolve quickly.

The stickiness comes from the way sugar behaves when heated. As it cools, it forms long chains that want to hold together. Add butter to the mix, and you get that characteristic toffee texture. Some people love it, others find it a bit much, but that's what makes toffees unique in the sweet world.

Which toffees are best for sharing?

Individually wrapped toffees are perfect for passing around. Classic varieties like treacle, butter, and cream toffees always go down well. For something special, try assorted toffee selections – they give everyone a chance to find their favourite.

If you're putting together a sweet buffet, toffees work brilliantly alongside other treats. They're more sophisticated than fizzy sweets but not as formal as luxury chocolates. Mix them with lollipops and pencils, laces and belts for a proper pick-and-mix experience.

Toffees bring back memories of childhood trips to the sweet shop, yet they're sophisticated enough for grown-up tastes too. Whether you prefer the traditional butterscotch variety or modern flavour combinations, there's a toffee out there waiting to become your new favourite.

And the best part? They last ages so that you can savour them one at a time, if you've got the willpower! Ready to explore our full range? We've got plenty of toffee varieties and even more sweet treats to discover. Or check out our guide to British confectionery traditions to learn more about the history behind these beloved sweets.

Read less